Tuesday, August 31, 2010

Help me Akademi Al-Quran

First of all, I am not a fan of Akedemi Al-Quran and I do not learn Quran from them.

I accidentally went to their website at:

They are promoting their products of course. At the right bottom corner, I saw the following hadith:

Nabi s.a.w pernah bersabda :
"Berapa ramai daripada kalangan pembaca, membaca Al-Quran ,tetapi ketika dia sedang membaca Al-Quran itu,Al-Quran pula melaknat dia".
Riwayat Al-Bukhari

Di antara sebab-sebab mereka dilaknati adalah kerana mereka membaca Al-Quran dengan tidak bertajwid seperti yang diajar oleh Nabi s.a.w..
  • Bagaimana pula dengan orang yang tidak tahu langsung membaca Al-Quran??
  • Layakkah mereka mendapat Syafaat Al-Quran di akhirat kelak??
  • Adakah Sah solat mereka??

I could not find this hadith in Bukhari when I flipped through the book but I find this hadith instead:

Aishah (May Allah be pleased with her) reported: The Messenger of Allah (PBUH) said, "The one who is proficient in the recitation of the Qur'an will be with the honourable and obedient scribes (angels) and he who recites the Qur'an and finds it difficult to recite, doing his best to recite it in the best way possible, will have a double reward.''
[Al-Bukhari and Muslim]


Proficient here means one who reads the Qur'an in accordance with the rules of "Ilm At-Tajwid'' (the science of the recitation of the Qur'an) as is evidenced from the words of Imam Bukhari's narration and the title given to the chapter.

This Hadith also highlights the merit of the reader of the Qur'an who does not know `Ilm At-Tajwid, and for that reason cannot read it fluently. But in spite of this, he reads it with great effort. He will be given double reward, one for the difficulty encountered in reciting it, and another for reading it. Safratun translated in the Hadith as scribes (angels) mean the angels that convey the Wahy (Revelation) to the Messenger of Allah. Imam Bukhari has taken it to mean "one who makes reconciliation''. The angels who bring Wahy and chastisement from Allah.

Well, if anyone could help me. 2 things:

1. Which book and the number of hadith in Bukhari is the hadith from the akademialquran are taken from?

2. Is there a contradictory to the two parts which were bolded in red above?


  1. Toro,
    The hadith from that website is FAKE.
    I've checked with few panel hadeeth @ Al-Fikrah (http://www.al-fikrah.net/index.php?name=Forums&file=viewtopic&t=16252) and this is what they concluded:

    1- Semua rangkai yang diberikan menyatakan bahawa ia tidak sabit daripada Nabi.

    2- RINGKASAN: Ia BUKAN hadis, tiada dalam Al-Bukhari.

    3- KENAPA sewenang-sewenangnya mereka cakap itu hadis Al-Bukhari??

    a) Ramai manusia yang tidak berhati-hati dalam mengungkapkan hadis.

    b) Ramai yang tidak pernah mengkhatamkan/ menghabiskan sebarang kitab hadis dengan lengkap.

    c) Ramai manusia yang masih jahil tentang ancaman Nabi tentang menipu atas nama Nabi. http://ad-diyari.com/fail_htm/hadis/al-bukhariy/0101-0150.htm#K106


  2. Salams bro. I've never heard of that hadith before. If it's a weak hadith or worse still a fake one, then Akademi Al-Quran must seriously look into their content.

  3. Amazing how people dare to lie and use religion as a mean to make money.

    Even worse, they are playing with hell fire. More like booking a place in hell fire.

    [Al-Bukhariy/ 106] Telah bercerita kepada kami `Aliy bin Al-Ja`d, dia berkata: Telah memberitahu kami Syu`bah, dia berkata: Telah memberitahu saya Mansur, dia berkata: Saya telah mendengar Rib`iy bin Hirasy berkata: Saya telah mendengar `Aliy berkata: Telah berkata Nabi: «Jangan antum berdusta ke atas saya, maka sesungguhnya sesiapa yang berdusta ke atas saya, maka dia akan masuk neraka».

  4. Oh and I don't think the webpage is linked with the TV 9 Akademi Al-Quran. Huhuu..

  5. i am not very proficient in this field, but here's my humble opinion:

    the second hadith said that 'those who recite with great effort', hence it means, if you put your effort to read Quran, try to read it in the best way possible, u will get rewarded.

    and the first hadith said that those who read Quran without using the correct tajweed will be condemned. in my understanding, 'without correct tajwid' might also implies 'reading the Quran sesuka kati' and without any effort to learn tajweed or try to recite it in the best way u can. because of this lack of effort (baca ikut suka hati dan malas nak belajar tajweed) he will be condemned. so i dont think these hadith contradict each other. if i am not mistaken, tajweed is very important because if we mispronounce the alphabet, making the wrong sounds and such, we might end up 'altering' the meaning of the verses. that's why tajweed is important. i think it is understandable why one should be condemned for this. But as Allah is All-Wise and All-Loving, He reward those who don't know how to recite Quran properly, PROVIDED they put their effort and try as best as they can.

    however tho, regarding the authenticity of the first hadith, I have no knowledge about that, sorry.


  6. Well the first hadith was very fishy because it means that anyone at all that reads Quran incorrectly or not according to tajwid will be cursed.

    The hadith was found to be a fake.

    As the second one, I found that in Sahih Bukhari. We will be rewarded double if we try to read the Quran with hardship.